Why is turkey the main dish on Thanksgiving?

13 days ago Iowa Capital Dispatch

Have you ever wondered why Thanksgiving revolves around turkey and not ham, chicken, venison, beef or corn?

Almost 9 in 10 Americans eat turkey during this festive meal, whether it’s roasted, deep-fried, grilled or cooked in any other way for the occasion.

You might believe it’s because of what the Pilgrims, a year after they landed in what’s now the state of Massachusetts, and their Indigenous Wampanoag guests ate during their first thanksgiving feast in 1621. Or that it’s because turkey is originally from the Americas.

But it has more to do with how Americans observed the holiday in the late 1800s than which poultry the Pilgrims ate while celebrating their bounty in 1621.

Two people dressed as Pilgrims sit atop a giant turkey float that is wearing a Pilgrim hat.

Did they or didn’t they eat it?

The only firsthand record of what the Pilgrims ate at the first thanksgiving feast comes from Edward Winslow. He noted that the Wampanoag leader, Massasoit, arrived with 90 men, and the two communities feasted together for three days.

Winslow wrote little about the menu, aside from mentioning five deer that the Wampanoag brought and that the meal included “fowle,” which could have been any number of wild birds found in the area, including ducks, geese and turkeys.

Historians do know that important ingredients of today’s traditional dishes were not available during that first Thanksgiving.

That includes potatoes and green beans. The likely absence of wheat flour and the scarcity of sugar in New England at the time ruled out pumpkin pie and cranberry sauce. Some sort of squash, a staple of Native American diets, was almost certainly served, along with corn and shellfish.

A resurrected tradition

Historians like me who have studied the history of food have found that most modern Thanksgiving traditions began in the mid-19th century, more than two centuries after the Pilgrims’ first harvest celebration.

The reinvention of the Pilgrims’ celebration as a national holiday was largely the work of Sarah Hale. Born in New Hampshire in 1784, as a young widow she published poetry to earn a living. Most notably, she wrote the nursery rhyme “Mary Had a Little Lamb.”

A woman dressed as a colonial-era settler grabs a live turkey.

In 1837, Hale became the editor of the popular magazine Godey’s Lady’s Book. Fiercely religious and family-focused, it crusaded for the creation of an annual national holiday of “Thanksgiving and Praise” commemorating the Pilgrims’ thanksgiving feast.

Hale and her colleagues leaned on 1621 lore for historical justification. Like many of her contemporaries, she assumed the Pilgrims ate turkey at their first feast because of the abundance of edible wild turkeys in New England.

This campaign took decades, partly due to a lack of enthusiasm among white Southerners. Many of them considered an earlier celebration among Virginia colonists in honor of supply ships that arrived at Jamestown in 1610 to be the more important precedent.

The absence of Southerners serving in Congress during the Civil War enabled President Abraham Lincoln to declare Thanksgiving a national holiday in 1863.

Turkey marketing campaign

Godey’s, along with other media, embraced the holiday, packing their pages with recipes from New England and menus that prominently featured turkey.

“We dare say most of the Thanksgiving will take the form of gastronomic pleasure,” Georgia’s Augusta Chronicle predicted in 1882. “Every person who can afford turkey or procure it will sacrifice the noble American fowl to-day.”

A painting depicting an old-fashioned, traditional Thanksgiving family feast

One reason for this: A roasted turkey makes a perfect celebratory centerpiece.

A second one is that turkey is also practical for serving to a large crowd. Turkeys are bigger than other birds raised or hunted for their meat, and it’s cheaper to produce a turkey than a cow or pig.
The bird’s attributes led Europeans to incorporate turkeys into their diets following their colonization of the Americas. In England, King Henry VIII regularly enjoyed turkey on Christmas day a century before the Pilgrims’ feast.

Christmas connection

The bird cemented its position as the favored Christmas dish in England in the mid-19th century.

One reason for this was that Ebenezer Scrooge in Charles Dickens’ “A Christmas Carol” sought redemption by replacing the impoverished Cratchit family’s meager goose with an enormous turkey.

Published in 1843, Dickens’ instantly best-selling depiction of the prayerful family meal would soon inspire Hale’s idealized Thanksgiving.

Although the historical record is hazy, I do think it’s possible that the Pilgrims ate turkey in 1621. It certainly was served at celebrations in New England throughout the colonial period.


The Conversation

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article
Continue reading...

Read On "Iowa Capital Dispatch"

More News On "Iowa Capital Dispatch"
BREAKING NEWS
23 minutes ago - NHL world reacts to historic five-goal performance 27 minutes ago - Recap: Avs blanked by Bruins 27 minutes ago - Elon Musk turns Twitter office rooms into bedrooms for 'tired' employees 27 minutes ago - Extreme Natural Events and Climate Change 28 minutes ago - Golden State Warriors suffer heartbreaking loss in unbelievabably crazy finish 33 minutes ago - 1,100 New York Times Employees to Go on 24-Hour Strike 38 minutes ago - After Teaching Him for Free, Michael Jordan’s Hall of Fame Coach Reveals the ‘Hardest Thing He Had To Overcome’ in Golf 40 minutes ago - [latest] Black Clover Movie Latest Spoilers, Leaked Summaries, Plot & More News 43 minutes ago - TV and Streaming Viewing Picks for December 8, 2022: how to watch Thursday Night Football 48 minutes ago - Rangers’ Kaapo Kakko showing potential, but goals hard to come by 49 minutes ago - OMEGA X legal battle against SPIRE begins, CEO Kang Seong Hee defiant to New York Times – Asian Junkie 50 minutes ago - Thompson nets 4 in 1st, 5 overall, as Buffalo tops Columbus 50 minutes ago - Judge goes back to Yankees as Giants, Padres examine options 50 minutes ago - How Streaming Has Rewritten the Script for Movies 57 minutes ago - Capitals finish season-long road trip 3-2-1 to stay afloat in East 58 minutes ago - Quick Recap: Ja Morant sets franchise-record for triple doubles in win over Thunder 1 hour ago - What kind of company do the striking HarperCollins workers face? 1 hour ago - 'The Amazing Race' Finale: 'Big Brother' couple Derek Xiao and Claire Rehfuss win Season 34 1 hour ago - Watch Durant, Irving combine for 62 points to lift Nets past Hornets 1 hour ago - 2023 Original Song Contenders (Part 3) 1 hour ago - Clippers vs. Heat Odds, Pick, Prediction: Offense Likely Limited in Miami (December 8) 1 hour ago - NBA roundup: Magic halt skid with OT win over Clippers 1 hour ago - The Amazing Race 34: Derek Xiao and Claire Rehfuss Winner Interview (2022) 1 hour ago - Richmond NGA product at home with Tigers' VFL program 1 hour ago - Giannis Antetokounmpo, Since ‘The Ladder Incident’, has averaged 36 and Tied 7’2″ Kareem Abdul-Jabbar 1 hour ago - Jazz Take Third Quarter Lead With Three Point Barrage 1 hour ago - Tigers trade Joe Jimenez for top-rated position player in Braves' system 1 hour ago - Knicks Light Up Injury-Riddled Hawks 1 hour ago - New York Times journalists will stage historic 24-hour strike after management and union fail to reach deal 1 hour ago - Avatar’s James Cameron on art, AI and outrage 2 hours ago - Ex-Theranos president Ramesh Balwani gets 13-year prison term in fraud case 2 hours ago - Sabres' Tage Thompson torments Blue Jackets with 5-point first period 2 hours ago - New York Times braces for 24-hour newsroom strike 3 hours ago - Exclusive For Boost Users! Stand The Chance To Win Tickets For Blackpink World Tour [Born Pink] Kuala Lumpur When Redeeming RM2 Rewards 3 hours ago - America’s most Googled term in 2022 is puzzling 3 hours ago - Edey stands tall as No. 4 Boilermakers rout Hofstra 85-66 3 hours ago - KEN PERROTTE: Canadian gun-control push should concern US gun-rights advocates 3 hours ago - CTB vs WF Dream11 Prediction, Fantasy Cricket Tips, Dream11 Team, Playing XI, Pitch Report, Injury Update- The Ford Trophy 3 hours ago - Germany busts far-right cell plotting to ‘overthrow state’ 3 hours ago - Some New York Times Employees Will Go On Strike For 24 Hours 3 hours ago - Harry & Meghan: King Charles and Prince William ‘to respond to any claims’ in Netflix series 3 hours ago - Holmes' former partner gets nearly 13 years in Theranos case 3 hours ago - Tage Thompson becomes first Sabres player with four goals in a period 3 hours ago - Men’s and women’s swimming and dive both place first at Big AI Invitational 3 hours ago - 1 Key Player The LA Clippers Could Trade Soon 3 hours ago - Watch Mars get eclipsed by the moon tonight on the free webcast 3 hours ago - Theranos ex-president sentenced to 13 years for fraud 3 hours ago - Federal cop shoots one dead inside Washington DC's Metro Center station, conductor hailed for saving lives 3 hours ago - Fresh demonstrations erupt in Tehran amid local reports huge crowds are in bid to overthrow regime 3 hours ago - Theranos case: Ramesh Balwani, former partner of Holmes, gets 13-year jail 3 hours ago - 'Most amazing nightmare of my life': Inside the Rihanna press trip that descended into disaster 3 hours ago - Top 5 news stories that drew attention among our HK readers in 2022 3 hours ago - John Lennon Compared 1 of His Solo Songs to Haiku 3 hours ago - Sunny Balwani, Elizabeth Holmes’ former partner, sentenced in Theranos fraud case - WEIS 3 hours ago - iSpace Could Become First Private Company to Achieve Moon Landing 3 hours ago - British royals brace for Harry and Meghan’s Netflix broadside 3 hours ago - Harry and Meghan 'betrayed the agreement they made with the Queen,' expert claims 4 hours ago - Mariners end quiet Winter Meetings by taking Chris Clarke in Rule 5 draft 4 hours ago - The US and the Holocaust: Documentarian Ken Burns examines the failure of Roosevelt to rescue the victims of the Nazis’ Final Solution 4 hours ago - EPHRAIM HARDCASTLE: Will the King remove Prince Harry's KCVO?
free geoip