Uddhav vs Eknath Shinde : Supreme Court To Hear Petitions Related To Shiv Sena Rift On January 13, 2023

2 months ago Live Law

The Supreme Court on Tuesday posted the batch of petitions filed by both the Uddhav Thackeray faction and the Eknath Sindhe faction in relation to the political crisis in the State of Maharashtra, for directions, on 13th January, 2023. The matter was mentioned before a bench comprising CJI DY Chandrachud and Justice PS Narasimha. The matter was initially supposed to be posted for directions on 29th November 2022.

CJI Chandrachud, while hearing the mentioning today remarked that the matter could be now posted in the month of January for directions. Senior Advocate Devadatt Kamat for Uddhav faction requested the hearings to be commenced at an earlier date. However, CJI Chandrachud stated that the same would not be possible owing to the following week being a miscellaneous week in the Supreme Court. He said–

"Next week won't be possible because it will be a miscellaneous week. It will not be possible for five judges to sit in a Constitution Bench. Let us keep this for directions on 13th January 2023."

On September 27, the Constitution Bench hearing the matter had rejected the plea made by Uddhav group to restrain the Election Commission of India from deciding the claim made by Shinde group that it is the real Shiv Sena.

Issues for consideration in the matter

The 3-judge bench comprising Chief Justice of India NV Ramana, Justice Krishna Murari and Justice Hima Kohli, that had referred the petitions to the Constitution Bench had framed the following 11 issues for its consideration -

A. Whether the notice of removal of the speaker restricts him from continuing the disqualification proceedings under Schedule X of the Indian Constitution as held by the Court in Nabam Rebia;

B. Whether a petition under Article 226 and Article 32 lies inviting a decision on a disqualification proceeding by the High Courts or the Supreme Court as the case may be;

C. Can a court hold that a member is deemed to be disqualified by virtue of his/her actions absent a decision by the Speaker?

D. What is the status of proceedings in the House during the pendency of disqualification petitions against the members?

E. If the decision of speaker that a member was incurred disqualification under the Tenth Schedule relates back to the date of the complaint, then what is the status of proceedings that took place during the pendency of the disqualification petition?

F. What is the impact of the removal of Para 3 of the Tenth Schedule? (which omitted "split" in a party as a defence against disqualification proceedings)

G. What is the scope of the power of the Speaker to determine the whip and leader of house of the legislative party?

H. What is the interplay with respect to the provisions of the Tenth Schedule?

I. Are intra-party questions amenable to judicial review? What is the scope of the same?

J. Power of the governor to invite a person to form the government and whether the same is amenable to judicial review?

K. What is the scope of the powers of Election Commission of India with respect to deter an ex parte split within a party.

Background of Petitions before the Constitution BenchPetition preferred by rebel Shiv Sena leader Eknath Shinde (now the Chief Minister) challenging the disqualification notices issued by the Deputy Speaker and plea filed by Bharat Gogawale and 14 other Shiv Sena MLA's seeking to restrain the Deputy Speaker from taking any action in the disqualification petition until the resolution for removal of Deputy Speaker is decided. On June 27, the division bench of Justices Surya Kant and JB Pardiwala had extended the time for the rebel MLAs to file written responses to the Deputy Speaker's disqualification notice till July 12.Petition filed by Shiv Sena Chief Whip Sunil Prabhu challenging the Maharashtra Governor's direction to the Chief Minister to prove majority of Maha Vikas Aghadi Government.Petition filed by Sunil Prabhu, the whip appointed by Uddhav Thackeray-led group, challenging the action of the newly elected Maharashtra Assembly Speaker recognizing the whip nominated by the Eknath Shinde group as the Chief Whip of Shiv Sena.Petition preferred by Mr. Subhash Desai, the General Secretary of the Shiv Sena assailing the decision of the Maharashtra Governor to invite Eknath Shinde to be the Chief Minister of Maharashtra and challenged the further proceedings of the State's Legislative Assembly held on 03.07.2022 and 04.07.2022 as 'illegal'.Petition preferred by 14 MLAs of Uddhav camp challenging the initiation of illegal disqualification proceedings against them under the Tenth Schedule by the newly elected Speaker.

Case Title: Subhash Desai v. Principal Secretary, Governor of Maharashtra And Ors. WP(C) No. 493/2022
Continue reading...

Read On "Live Law"
More News On "Live Law"
13 minutes ago - “They did that to discredit us”- The ‘Harry & Meghan’ Director Insists That She DID Reach Out To Buckingham For Comments on Docuseries 15 minutes ago - Magicycle Launches Its First Full-Suspension e-Bike, Mixes Performance and Comfort 18 minutes ago - Palestinian Foreign Minister Slams Abraham Accords As Failure Over Lack Of New Signatories 19 minutes ago - Turkey hit by many strong aftershocks after 7.8 earthquake, 1,800 dead so far 21 minutes ago - Earthquake rocks Türkiye and Syria killing around 1,200 people 45 minutes ago - Turkey earthquake live updates: At least 1,200 dead in Turkey, Syria after powerful quake 47 minutes ago - Israel-Palestine conflict: Why Benjamin Netanyahu is yet to launch a new war on the Gaza Strip 48 minutes ago - Strain Gauge Converters Market Size [2023-2029] -SENECA, PHOENIX CONTACT, Pepperl+Fuchs, Datexel 51 minutes ago - 100 years ago this week, Einstein took his one and only trip to Israel 55 minutes ago - Israel not prepared for major earthquake, experts say 55 minutes ago - Beyoncé emerges as Grammys queen; Styles wins album honor 58 minutes ago - Grammys Buzz: Memorable Moments From Music's Big Night 1 hour ago - Grammy 2023: in a night dedicated to Beyoncé and Harry Styles, the list of all the winners 1 hour ago - Devastating quake that rocked Turkey and Syria, kills more than 1,300 (photos) 1 hour ago - EU rushes rescuers, satellite help to Turkey 1 hour ago - Rapist cop David Carrick's urinated on victims and kept them locked in small cupboard in humiliating attacks 1 hour ago - Grammys 2023: Check out the winners Code List 1 hour ago - Turkey earthquake: Are flights and holidays cancelled? 1 hour ago - Grammys 2023: The complete winners list 1 hour ago - Turkey and Syria earthquake live updates: 7.8-magnitude quake kills hundreds 1 hour ago - Jumeirah Group expands presence in Europe with key acquisition in Geneva 2 hours ago - Powerful quake rocks Turkey and Syria, kills more than 1,300 2 hours ago - Fans Feel Sorry For Adele’s Boyfriend Rich Paul After Her Viral Moment With Dwayne “The Rock” Johnson at Grammys 2023 2 hours ago - Check out the best dressed on the 2023 Grammys red carpet 2 hours ago - Camila Cabello flashes her legs in a thigh-split black gown at Universal's Grammy's afterparty 2 hours ago - Know About Charles Kimbrough’s Net Worth And Career 2 hours ago - Beyoncé wins 4 Grammys for all-time record; Harry Styles takes album of year 2 hours ago - Crews work to prevent explosion at site of burning derailed train in Ohio as residents are urged to flee 2 hours ago - UAE: Syrian, Turkish expats reach out to families back home as earthquakes strike region 2 hours ago - 3.5 mi South of Cheektowaga, Erie County, New York, USA, on Monday, Feb 6, 2023 at 6:15 am (GMT -5) 2 hours ago - Major Aftershock of 7.8 Intensity Strikes Turkey: What are These, How Many Usual After Earthquake? 2 hours ago - Turkey Earthquake LIVE Updates: Another 7.5 Magnitude Quake Hits Turkey 2 hours ago - The ADHD medication shortage is getting worse. There's no easy solution, experts say. 2 hours ago - A Closer Look At The Most Iconic Grammys 2023 Outfits And Best Dressed Stars From... 2 hours ago - Ben Affleck's bored expression at the Grammys becomes a meme 2 hours ago - From raggaeton to Iran: 5 key moments from the Grammys 3 hours ago - ICC Women’s T20 World Cup: Australia’s Meg Lanning – ‘There’s a fair bit I still want to achieve’ 3 hours ago - T20 leagues with cricketing ecosystem will survive, rest will fade away: Sourav Ganguly 3 hours ago - Officials advise evacuation over explosion concerns after train derailment in Ohio 3 hours ago - FULL LIST: Tems and other Grammy Award winners in 2023 3 hours ago - Guitar at the Grammys 2023: Wet Leg, Nirvana, Turnstile and More 3 hours ago - Discovering The Financial Success Of Charles Kimbrough! 3 hours ago - Beyoncé set a new record for the most Grammy wins ever 3 hours ago - Madonna in surprise Grammys appearance to praise 'provocative' artists 4 hours ago - Truex grabs exhibition win; caution flags dominate race 4 hours ago - Chris Brown explodes and mocks Robert Glasper after he loses out on Grammy Award 4 hours ago - In The News for Feb. 6 : How will the loonie fare in 2023? 4 hours ago - Megan Fox and Machine Gun Kelly attend Grammy afterparty 4 hours ago - Beyonce emerges as Grammys queen; Styles wins album honor - Music - Arts & Culture 4 hours ago - Grammys 2023: Beyoncé makes history and Harry Styles wins Album of the Year 4 hours ago - Major Quake Kills Hundreds Across Turkey, Syria 4 hours ago - James Corden presents Grammy to Beyonce and parties with A-list before return to UK 4 hours ago - Light Start: Twitter’s “good” bots, iPhone 15 Ultra (?), Starship Orbits and a $50,000 iPhone 1 4 hours ago - 65th Grammy Awards 2023:List Of Winners 4 hours ago - Adele's awkward reaction to Trevor Noah's cringe shower gag spotted by Grammys viewers 4 hours ago - Grammy winners 2023: See who won 4 hours ago - Chris Gayle Recalls 175-run Knock in IPL 2013, Says ‘it was Like the World Stopped’, WATCH 4 hours ago - Health minister hits back at claim government no longer talking to unions on pay – UK politics live 4 hours ago - Tems Bags First Grammy Award [FULL LIST OF WINNERS] 4 hours ago - Margaret Qualley puts on a cosy display with her fiancé Jack Antonoff at the Grammys
free geoip