Oppression or Liberation? Sweating Over Modest Clothing

1 month ago Patheos

Sitting with Soraya under the shade of a palm tree along Balneario del Escambrón’s sun-soaked sand in San Juan, Puerto Rico, I could barely stand the heat.

It was 88° F (31° C) with high humidity. Sweat was pouring down my face as I listened to her talk about her experience as a Puerto Rican convert to Islam.

Amidst the discussion, she noticed my perspiration and laughed. “Hermano, you think you’re hot?! Imagine being dressed in a black abaya [loose over garment] and hijab!”

Bringing the topic up, I asked her why she chose to wear hijab — or Islamic headscarf. Soraya replied, “before I became Muslim, men were always judging my body by its curves, by how tight my clothes were and how round I was in certain places. Wearing abaya donning the hijab, takes those evaluations out of the conversation and forces people to take me for who I actually am, what I say, what I do — not what I wear.”

Even so, Soraya still gets stopped on San Juan’s streets and asked about her clothing, her religion, or whether she feels “oppressed.”

For many, the “controversial fabric” is a symbol of subjugation and segregation. Especially right now, as protests continue to rage in Iran after the death of 22-year-old Mahsa Ahmini who was killed while resisting the country’s compulsory laws forcing women to wear hijab, the headscarf has once again become a trademark of tyranny and functional emblem of fundamentalist religion.

And yet, for millions of religious women, headscarves, veils, and others forms of conservative clothing remain a prized tradition, a fashion statement, or — as with Soraya — a means of liberation.

Although it is impossible to judge the various intentions, diverse experiences, and interior motivations of women across the globe, the following explores the material contexts and colonial pasts that are imperative to keep in mind when discussing hijabs, veils, and other forms of modest, religious dress.

Holy couture.

Like Soraya, Megan also struggles with hot and humid weather in the Sunshine State.

She wrote that as an Apostolic Pentecostal, she belongs to a group of believers that adheres to standards of dress that promote modesty, based on scriptural interpretations of covering “with a little Bible belt flavor and fashion thrown in.”

That means her body is covered from knees to neck to the middle of the bicep “in every season, no matter the heat index.”

“Summer in Florida,” Megan wrote, “is not the easiest time to be Apostolic….the daily task of choosing an outfit becomes something of a test of ingenuity.”

It also becomes an opportunity, she said, to be “modestly stylish, approachable, and even attractive.”

Similar to Megan, many Muslim women choose more than whether to wear modest clothing, but also how to wear it and how to express themselves through it.

For them, “pious fashion” is a context specific styling and creative process based on using a range of available clothing and accessories that are both appropriate and attractive.

In her book Pious Fashion: How Muslim Women Dress, religious studies scholar Liz Bucar “argues that modest clothing represents much more than social control or religious orthodoxy.”

Analyzing fashion trends -- and listening to Muslim women -- in Tehran, Yogyakarta, and Istanbul, Bucar challenges readers to go beyond common Western perceptions about the “veil” to discover a wide world of women’s Islamic fashion that is colorful, aesthetically adventurous, and a major multimillion-dollar moneymaker for the fashion industry.

Their clothing – like all fashion – is a social practice contingent upon a mix of local aesthetic values, moral authority, embodied consumption, and sartorial selfhood.

One woman’s oppression is another woman’s liberation?

Along with Megan and Soraya’s experiences, Bucar’s work invites serious questions around what counts as oppression and what counts as liberation according to contemporary liberal discourse.

For the student of religion, it also confronts us with conundrums around Western perceptions of veiling, modest clothing, and other religious practices broadly conceived of, or condemned, as repressive or antidemocratic.

In her enlightening ethnography on feminine pietistic movements in Cairo, Egypt, anthropologist Saba Mahmood addressed such questions head on.

Talking to women who were part of an “Islamic revival” in Egypt in the mid-1990s, Mahmood takes concepts like “piety,” “devotion,” and “feminism” and flips them on their head.

To her astonishment, the women taking part in the Egyptian mosque movements were not interested in either liberal-secular visions of feminist liberation or Islamist visions of a theocratic state.

Showing how liberal-secular conceptions of individual agency fail to account for pietist women’s moral frameworks, she shared stories of how these women cultivated virtues and embodied practices within normative frames deemed illiberal, unsecular, and patriarchal.

Their actions, she famously wrote, may not be liberal, but they were full of agency.

Fashioning liberal societies.

Although directly addressing Salafi women in Cairo, Mahmood’s conclusions can also be extended to other contexts where people do not accept or apply liberal secular norms.

They are also relevant for those who seek to uphold such norms in rather illiberal ways.

Take, for example, so-called “burqa bans” and “anti-hijab” laws.

Multiple states have banned the burqa – a full body covering, with a mesh screen over the eyes -- introduced some form of legislation limiting the wearing of burqas, niqabs (facial veil), or hijabs in certain places or positions, including European nations like Austria, Belgium, Bulgaria, Denmark, France, the Netherlands, Norway, and Switzerland as well as Cameroon, Chad, China, Gabon, Morocco, Republic of the Congo, Sri Lanka, Tajikistan, Tunisia, Uzbekistan, and the province of Quebec in Canada.

In the name of liberal democracy – or national security – these states have banned specific sartorial practices seen by some as religious obligations.

In liberal societies, this poses a dilemma, as they are meant to be spheres wherein all citizens are free and equal in terms of rights, so long as those freedoms and rights do not impinge those of others.

This brings us back to the questions and challenges posed by Mahmood’s research and the cases we considered above: what counts as oppression? What counts as liberation? Who gets to decide? And how might we consider modest fashion in light of such considerations?

What to do with headscarf politics and “pious fashions”

In the end, and as with most things “religious,” there is no easy answer to these inquiries.

When it comes to whether modest clothing is inherently oppressive or explicitly liberative, we must take multiple, and divergent, factors and tendencies into consideration.

Headscarf politics and social norms around “pious fashion” – Christian, Muslim, or otherwise – are far more complex than we give them credit.

Whether, why, and how women wear certain articles of clothing is not just a matter of divine – or political – fiat, but one where historical, cultural, and colonial contingencies all play a role.

Even in Iran, the headscarf has many meanings serving women as both symbol of resistance and oppression.

The danger comes when we try to simplify and too-quickly categorize an issue with multiple applications, interpretations, and meanings dependent on cultural context and individual experience.

At the very least, we might consider this: while religious women may be singled out for having to imaginatively negotiate their clothing within strict social boundaries, one might say the same for many of us making choices about what to wear or not to wear, how to look or how others might look at us.

For the student of religion, the answers may not be easy to come by, but the questions are well-worth sweating over.

Further Reading:

•Pious Fashion: How Muslim Women Dress, by Liz Bucar

•Politics of Piety: The Islamic Revival and the Feminist Subject, by Saba Mahmood

•“Being an Apostolic Fashionista,” by Megan Geiger Keith

Continue reading...

Read On "Patheos"
More News On "Patheos"
23 minutes ago - Kirstie Alley, ‘Cheers’ and ‘Veronica’s Closet’ star, dead at 71 26 minutes ago - Here's What Stood Out in Celtics' Win vs. Raptors: Increased Energy and Better Ball Security the Difference-Makers in Second Half Surge 29 minutes ago - Phoenix Suns blitzed by Mavericks in Dallas again 31 minutes ago - TUCKER CARLSON: This isn't how our system is supposed to work 32 minutes ago - Clippers’ Kawhi Leonard reacts to first game-winner since ACL tear 34 minutes ago - Kirstie Alley's 2 Kids: Everything to Know 34 minutes ago - Coup’s Takeaways: HEAT Run Out Of Time Against Shorthanded Grizzlies 35 minutes ago - Keys to the Game: Celtics 116, Raptors 110 37 minutes ago - Golden Knights Hand Boston Its First Home Loss in 4-3 SO Win 42 minutes ago - Leonard returns, hits game-winner as Clippers beat Hornets 43 minutes ago - US Supreme Court hears case pitting free speech against LGBTQ rights 1 hour ago - Ex-Buccaneer Takes Shot at Tom Brady’s Performance 1 hour ago - Instant analysis: Shai Gilgeous-Alexander leads OKC Thunder past Atlanta Hawks 1 hour ago - Six years later, Warriors look back at Klay Thompson’s 60-point, 11-dribble game 1 hour ago - Cricket 2022: Ellyse Perry cops ban after Sydney Sixers' loss in WBBL final 1 hour ago - Bruins only part way to their game 1 hour ago - Who Were Kirstie Alley’s Husbands? How Many Kids Did She Have? 1 hour ago - Four takeaways as Celtics defeat Raptors 116-110 using huge 3rd quarter 1 hour ago - Kirstie Alley, Emmy-winning actress and ‘Cheers’ star, dies at 71 1 hour ago - Celtics Show Patience Pays as Tatum & Brown Deal Raptors Loss in 'Measurement Game' 1 hour ago - Bucks 109, Magic 102: Markelle Fultz scores 20 points but losing streak continues 1 hour ago - IPL Auction 2023: 3 Australian Players That Punjab Kings Can Target 1 hour ago - Magic Fight Until the End, But Fall Short to Bucks 1 hour ago - Sources: Rumors about AEW roster attitude toward Regal, coaching ‘completely inaccurate’ 1 hour ago - NFL Live Betting Week 13: How We’re Live Betting Saints-Bucs On Monday Night Football 1 hour ago - UCLA Storms Back, Wins Second NCAA Women's Soccer Title 1 hour ago - Live updates: Saints 10, Bucs 3 (third quarter) 1 hour ago - Mavericks vs. Suns live score, updates, highlights: MVP candidates Luka Doncic and Devin Booker go head-to-head 1 hour ago - Buccaneers Could Eye Top Head Coach to Replace Todd Bowles: Analyst 1 hour ago - Hawks’ Trae Young, McMillan try to smooth over dispute 1 hour ago - Tafara Gapare, UMass breeze past Albany, 87-73 2 hours ago - Who is Michael Avenatti? 2 hours ago - Late goals from UCLA doom UNC women's soccer in 3-2 national championship loss 2 hours ago - Man who shot Lady Gaga’s dog walker and stole bulldogs sentenced to 21 years 2 hours ago - Jason Reitman Hands Ghostbusters: Afterlife Sequel Directing Reins to Gil Kenan 2 hours ago - Andy Cohen Featured On Meghan Markle’s Podcast And Awkwardly Forgets That He’s Previously Met The Duchess Of Sussex 2 hours ago - Young Easthampton climate activist scores royal audience at Celtics game 2 hours ago - Knight, Clooney, U2 feted at Kennedy Center Honors 2 hours ago - "TK [Tony Khan] will release him now" - Wrestling fans lose their minds over wild claims about WWE legend's potential AEW exit 2 hours ago - ABC News avoids Amy Robach, TJ Holmes being benched from 'GMA' as extramarital affair makes headlines 3 hours ago - Saints vs. Buccaneers live score, updates, highlights from NFL 'Monday Night Football' game 3 hours ago - Wenzhou ups efforts for trade, SMEs 3 hours ago - Raw results, live blog: High Stakes Poker 3 hours ago - Gisele Bundchen Leaves Another Comment On Ex Tom Brady’s Instagram After Divorce 3 hours ago - JUST IN: Bell Tiltrotor Wins Billion Dollar Helo Contract 3 hours ago - Man who shot Lady Gaga's dog walker sentenced to 21 years in jail after taking plea deal 3 hours ago - Joe Biden Pokes Fun At George Clooney’s Marriage In Kennedy Center Honors Speech 3 hours ago - Bell beats out Sikorsky to produce US Army’s new assault helicopter 3 hours ago - Report: Lakers tried to get Terry Rozier in 3-team Donovan Mitchell trade over summer 3 hours ago - SJHN Daily: Imama Suspended 4 Games for Ugly Kniazev Board 3 hours ago - 12/5 WWE RAW TV RESULTS: Doucette’s “alt perspective” report on Usos vs. Elias/Riddle tag title match, JBL poker tournament, two triple threat matches 3 hours ago - Tens of thousands still in the dark after 'targeted' attacks on North Carolina power substations 3 hours ago - Neymar scores, Brazil beats South Korea 4-1 at World Cup 3 hours ago - Qatar World Cup 2022 Schedule: Tuesday, December 6 3 hours ago - 2022 Heisman finalists (Stetson Bennett, really?): Here’s who should win CFB’s top individual prize 3 hours ago - Harry and Meghan docuseries trailer appears to use unrelated paparazzi footage 3 hours ago - 5 things on World Cup, Day 16: Brazilian carnival, Asian agony 3 hours ago - Man who shot Lady Gaga’s dog walker gets 21 years in prison 3 hours ago - Lakers vs. Cavaliers Preview: The Anthony Davis revenge tour continuous 3 hours ago - Man Who Shot Lady Gaga's Dog Walker & Stole Her Bulldogs Sentenced to 21 Years in Prison
free geoip